Two Markets, Three Brokers
COL Financial and First Metro Sec both put you on the Philippine Stock Exchange, buying shares of companies like SM, Ayala, or BDO directly. GoTrade puts you on the US market instead, buying fractional shares of companies like Apple or an S&P 500 ETF. That single difference, which market you're actually trading on, shapes almost everything else: the regulator overseeing your broker, how your fees are calculated, and even which recent tax change applies to you.
This guide assumes you've already decided roughly which market you want exposure to, local PSE shares or US stocks, and are now comparing the brokers that get you there. If you're still weighing that bigger decision, our Philippine stocks vs US stocks guide covers the tradeoffs in more depth before you pick a platform.
COL Financial vs First Metro Sec vs GoTrade at a Glance
| Factor | COL Financial | First Metro Sec | GoTrade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum deposit | ₱1,000 (COL Starter) | ₱1,000, or $100 for a USD account | $1 (~₱56) |
| What you trade | PSE-listed stocks | PSE-listed stocks | US-listed stocks and ETFs (fractional) |
| Online commission | 0.25% of trade value or ₱20, whichever is higher | 0.25% of trade value or ₱20, whichever is higher | Built into the buy/sell spread (roughly 0.5%-2%), plus a separate FX fee |
| Funding from PH | Bank bills pay (BDO, BPI, Metrobank, AUB, Chinabank, more), or GCash bills pay | Bank bills pay, over-the-counter, or GCash/Maya bills pay | GCash or Maya, linked directly in-app |
| Account activation | A few business days for document review | A few business days for document review | Typically same day |
| Regulator | Philippine SEC, PSE-member broker | Philippine SEC, PSE-member broker | Labuan, Malaysia license; introducing broker to a US FINRA/SEC member |
| Best suited to | Beginners who want simple, direct PSE access | Investors who want a bank-backed broker and USD options | Anyone starting with pocket change and wanting US names |
The Commission Math Nobody Explains Well
Here's the part most comparisons skip: for a typical retail trade, COL Financial and First Metro Sec cost almost exactly the same, because both follow the same PSE-standard online commission, 0.25% of the gross trade value or ₱20, whichever is higher, plus three regulatory pass-through charges that are identical across every PSE broker: 12% VAT on the commission, a 0.005% PSE transaction fee, and a 0.01% SCCP clearing fee.
What changed recently, and what most older guides haven't caught up to, is the stock transaction tax. Under Republic Act 12214, the Capital Markets Efficiency Promotion Act (CMEPA), this tax on selling PSE-listed shares dropped from 0.6% to 0.1% of the gross selling price, effective July 1, 2025. Here's what that does to a ₱10,000 round trip (buying then later selling ₱10,000 worth of stock) through COL Financial or First Metro Sec:
- Buying ₱10,000 worth of stock: ₱25 commission + ₱3 VAT + ₱0.50 PSE fee + ₱1 SCCP fee ≈ ₱29.50, about 0.30% of the trade
- Selling ₱10,000 worth of stock (new 0.1% tax): ₱25 commission + ₱3 VAT + ₱0.50 PSE fee + ₱1 SCCP fee + ₱10 transaction tax ≈ ₱39.50, about 0.40% of the trade
- Round trip total: roughly ₱69, about 0.69% of the ₱10,000 traded, down from around 1.19% before the July 2025 tax cut (when the sell-side tax alone was ₱60 instead of ₱10)
GoTrade's cost structure is shaped differently because none of this applies, the stock transaction tax only taxes PSE-listed shares, and GoTrade doesn't touch the PSE at all. Instead, its cost lives in the buy/sell spread (roughly 0.5% to 2%, disclosed in-app before you confirm a trade), a separate foreign exchange fee (roughly 0.3% to 1%), and a small trading fee (roughly 0.15% to 0.30%, minimum $0.10) that covers pass-through US regulatory charges. Stacked together, a round trip on GoTrade commonly runs somewhere in the 1.5%-2% range, noticeably higher than the post-CMEPA cost of a PSE trade through COL Financial or First Metro Sec, though you're paying for a completely different market and a dramatically lower entry point. GoTrade also charges roughly a 3% fee on e-wallet deposits and a flat $5 fee on local-currency withdrawals, separate from the per-trade costs above.
Opening an Account From the Philippines
COL Financial offers three tiers: COL Starter at a ₱1,000 minimum, built for beginners with basic platform access; COL Plus at ₱25,000, adding real-time data and deeper research tools for more active traders; and COL Premium at ₱1,000,000, aimed at high-net-worth clients who want priority support. Most first-time investors open a COL Starter account, submit a government ID, and wait a few business days for verification before funding and placing their first trade.
First Metro Sec, the online brokerage arm of First Metro Investment Corporation under the Metrobank Group, keeps a similar ₱1,000 minimum for a standard peso account, with the option to instead open a $100-minimum USD-denominated account if you specifically want to trade dollar securities. Its backing by one of the Philippines' largest banking groups is often cited as a reason more conservative investors lean toward it over an independent broker.
GoTrade has the lowest friction of the three by a wide margin. Signup happens in the app, identity verification runs against a government ID, and GCash or Maya links directly for funding, no bills-pay step required. Most users are verified and placing their first trade the same day, versus a multi-day review window for either PSE broker. For a deeper look at how GoTrade stacks up against a full international broker rather than a local one, see our GoTrade vs IBKR comparison.
Funding and Getting Your Money Back Out
Both COL Financial and First Metro Sec fund through partner banks (BDO, BPI, Metrobank, AUB, Chinabank, UnionBank, PNB, and more via online bills pay) plus, more recently, GCash and Maya as e-wallet bills-pay channels. The e-wallet route typically carries a ₱20 convenience fee and a short delay, next business day for COL Financial, roughly two trading days for First Metro Sec. Bank bills pay through partner banks is often free and similarly timed.
GoTrade skips the bills-pay step entirely, GCash and Maya connect directly inside the app for near-instant funding, though GoTrade applies its own roughly 3% fee on e-wallet deposits. Withdrawals back to a Philippine bank or e-wallet carry a flat $5 fee on GoTrade's end. COL Financial and First Metro Sec proceeds settle into your brokerage account and withdraw to a linked bank account within a few business days, with no flat per-withdrawal fee.
Regulation and Where Your Shares Actually Sit
COL Financial and First Metro Sec are both PSE-member brokers regulated directly by the Philippine SEC. Shares you buy through either one are held in your name through the PSE's own settlement and custody infrastructure, the same investor-protection framework that applies to any Philippine-licensed stockbroker, including oversight from the Capital Markets Integrity Corporation on trading conduct.
GoTrade's structure is different because it isn't trading PSE shares at all. It operates through Gotrade Securities Inc, licensed in Labuan, Malaysia (license SL/20/0014), acting as an introducing broker to Alpaca Securities LLC, a broker-dealer regulated in the US under FINRA and the SEC, with SIPC coverage protecting custodied securities up to $500,000. That's a meaningfully different regulatory chain than a PSE-member broker, not better or worse outright, but worth understanding since none of the Philippine SEC's investor-protection mechanisms for local brokers apply to a cross-border platform like GoTrade.
None of this is personalized investment advice. Confirm current licensing, fee schedules, and account terms directly on each broker's own site before funding an account, since all three have adjusted terms before.
Where Each Broker Actually Wins
| COL Financial wins when | First Metro Sec wins when | GoTrade wins when |
|---|---|---|
| You want a long-established, independent PSE broker with tiered research access as you grow | You'd rather trade through a bank-backed brokerage with a USD account option | You want to start with a token amount and fund straight from an e-wallet |
| You're buying Philippine blue chips and want the lowest-friction COL Starter tier | You already bank with Metrobank or a sister institution | You specifically want exposure to US companies or an S&P 500 ETF |
| You plan to scale up to COL Plus for real-time data later | You want dollar-denominated trading without opening a separate international brokerage | You're fine with same-day activation over a multi-day review window |
For investors specifically weighing GoTrade against mutual-fund-style apps rather than another PSE broker, our best robo-advisor and investment apps guide compares it against GInvest and Seedbox, two very different entry points into investing from inside GCash.
A Simple Way to Decide
Start with the market, not the broker. If you want to own shares of Philippine companies directly, COL Financial and First Metro Sec get you there at nearly identical per-trade cost, so the decision comes down to which account tier structure or parent company you'd rather deal with. If you want exposure to US companies and are starting with an amount small enough that a $1 minimum matters, GoTrade is built specifically for that, at the cost of a different, generally higher fee structure and a non-Philippine regulatory chain.
There's nothing stopping an investor from holding more than one of these accounts at once, a COL Starter account for PSE exposure and a GoTrade account for US names is a common combination among Filipino investors who want both markets without over-committing to either broker on day one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Check active GCash promos before funding a GoTrade account, or read the full GoTrade vs IBKR breakdown if you're weighing a bigger international broker next.
View GCash Deals → GoTrade vs IBKR Guide →